Resources>Reimbursement Rates

Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield Behavioral Health Reimbursement Rates in Wisconsin (2026)

FUSE TEAM
September 21, 2026Updated November 10, 20267 min read

Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield pays Wisconsin clinicians by license, and every Wisconsin network uses the same standard rates. In its November 2026 files, the standard rate for a 60-minute therapy session (CPT 90837) is $131.96 for counselors, clinical social workers, marriage and family therapists and psychiatric nurse practitioners, $152.00 for psychologists and $178.00 for psychiatrists. A clinician listed at a different amount has a separate contract with Anthem.

In Wisconsin, Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield is a trade name, and Anthem’s 2024 Wisconsin provider disclosure names three Elevance Health companies behind it. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Wisconsin underwrites its PPO and indemnity plans, Compcare Health Services Insurance Corporation underwrites its HMO and POS plans and sells its individual marketplace plans, and Wisconsin Collaborative Insurance Company underwrites its Well Priority HMO and POS plans. Under the federal Transparency in Coverage rule, Anthem publishes the negotiated rates behind those plans in machine readable files and replaces them every month.

This page is Fuse’s aggregation of those files. Our software read all 16 of Anthem’s November 2026 Wisconsin network files in full, 67 gigabytes of pricing once unpacked, kept every dollar-denominated fee schedule rate for the three CPT codes below, matched each listed NPI against the federal NPPES registry, kept individual behavioral health clinicians whose registered practice location is in Wisconsin, and computed statistics across distinct provider-rate pairs so a clinician appearing in many plans counts once per distinct rate. Anthem publishes every state’s files in one national index mixed with BlueCard mirrors of other Blues plans, so isolating genuine Wisconsin arrangements is the first methodology decision the rest of the analysis stands on.

The 16 files are every Wisconsin rate file in Anthem’s November index. They cover its Blue Access PPO, Blue Preferred HMO and POS, Blue Priority and PathWays individual networks. Transparency in Coverage files cover commercial plans only, so Medicare Advantage and BadgerCare Plus rates are not included. An earlier version of this page read only one of the 16 files, so it missed about 3,800 clinicians.

Anthem’s Negotiated Behavioral Health Rates in Wisconsin by CPT Code

The table below reflects November 2026 data for three commonly billed codes across Anthem’s Wisconsin network.

CPT Code Description Mean Negotiated Rate Median Negotiated Rate Min Max Unique NPI Count
90791 Psychiatric Diagnostic Evaluation $272.08 $156.00 $79.79 $1,086.03 9,681
90837 Psychotherapy, 60 minutes $252.70 $150.43 $77.97 $915.55 9,694
96130 Psychological Testing Evaluation, 1st hour $269.44 $156.07 $67.61 $966.35 9,563

Rates extracted from Anthem’s November 2026 Wisconsin machine readable files.

The mean for a 60-minute session ($252.70) is about two-thirds higher than the median ($150.43). That is a wider gap than at any other Blue plan Fuse has measured. The next widest is Anthem in Ohio, where the mean is 49 percent above the median. The diagnostic evaluation and testing codes look the same in Wisconsin. Separate contracts list some clinicians at far higher rates, up to $915.55 for 90837, through the same settings and claim types as the standard rate.

Why is the median $150.43 when most therapists are listed at $131.96? A clinician with a separate contract appears once for each rate they hold, and those extra rates are usually higher, so they pull the median up.

Does Anthem Pay Wisconsin Clinicians Differently by Network or License?

By license. Each license has one standard 90837 rate, and it is the same in every Wisconsin network file. Here is each standard rate and the share of each license listed at it:

  • Counselors, clinical social workers and marriage and family therapists. $131.96, for 80 percent.
  • Psychiatric nurse practitioners. Also $131.96, for 60 percent.
  • Psychologists. $152.00, about 15 percent more, for 57 percent.
  • Psychiatrists. $178.00, about 35 percent more, for 48 percent.

The network matters only through the separate contracts each file includes. Every network file has the same 90837 median, $131.96, and 61 percent of clinicians listed in more than one file have the same rate in each. One contract covering 978 clinicians pays $141.20 in the Blue Access and Blue Preferred files but does not appear in the Blue Priority or PathWays files. About 15 percent of therapists also have a separate contract at $200 or more, and about 17 percent have at least one rate below $131.96. Anthem’s Ohio rates follow the same pattern, with one standard rate per license across its networks.

The files are snapshots that Anthem replaces monthly, so these figures will drift. The extraction month above is the anchor.

Does Wisconsin Require Anthem to Pay the Same Rate for Telehealth?

No. Georgia requires insurers to pay telehealth at the in-person rate, and Ohio requires them to cover telehealth without setting the rate. Wisconsin requires neither. A commercial telehealth mandate (a proposed insurance statute, section 632.871) appeared in the Governor’s budget in 2021, 2023 and 2025, and the Legislature’s budget committee removed it each time. The 2025-27 budget signed in July 2025 does not contain it, so whether a virtual 90837 pays the office rate in Wisconsin is decided by the contract.

The state’s own Medicaid program went the other way. A 2019 law (Wisconsin Statute 49.45(61)) requires ForwardHealth to reimburse covered services delivered through interactive telehealth, and ForwardHealth policy pays distant-site providers the same rate as face-to-face care, with audio-only phone visits allowed where they are functionally equivalent. If much of your caseload is virtual, read the telehealth clause in your Anthem contract before assuming the rates above apply to video sessions, and raise it at renewal.

Who Reviews Behavioral Health Care for Anthem Wisconsin Plans?

For Anthem’s Wisconsin commercial and Medicare Advantage plans, it is Carelon Behavioral Health. Carelon’s Wisconsin provider handbook addendum says it provides utilization management on behalf of those plans. That does not prove every employer plan uses it, so check each patient. The addendum sends prior authorization and benefit questions to Availity or to the phone number on the back of the member’s ID card.

Carelon’s February 2023 Wisconsin quick reference guide also sends behavioral health credentialing questions to Carelon, and address changes to Carelon’s provider portal and your CAQH profile. When you join the network or add a clinician, ask which route your application should take, because an application in the wrong queue is an avoidable delay.

How Does Wisconsin Medicaid Pay for Therapy?

From a fixed fee schedule with two tiers. Psychiatrists, prescribing psychiatric nurses and doctoral-level psychologists get the higher rate, and master’s-level clinicians get the lower one. The claim’s modifier tells ForwardHealth which tier applies.

The rates rose 15 percent in January 2022, and some codes got another 5 percent from federal pandemic relief. ForwardHealth’s January 2026 increases under the 2025-27 budget left outpatient mental health out, so these rates have not risen since 2022. You can look up each code in ForwardHealth’s interactive fee schedule on the state portal. BadgerCare Plus HMOs set their own rates, which can differ from that schedule.

The schedule is set by the state, not negotiated. Anthem’s rates are negotiated, so comparing your Anthem contract with the Medicaid rate for your tier shows how much room your contract leaves.

What This Means for Your Practice

Every number above depends on the choices described earlier, from which files we read to which clinicians we kept. Different reasonable filters would move the averages, so read the table as a market reference, not anyone’s contract.

As of December 31, 2025, federal shortage data designated 174 mental health professional shortage areas in Wisconsin, covering roughly 2.2 million residents, with well under half of estimated need met. A clinician deciding whether to renegotiate is not negotiating from surplus. The network needs coverage, and Anthem’s own files show what it already pays other Wisconsin clinicians for the same codes. Pull what Anthem actually paid your practice per code from your remittances, set it against your contracted schedule and the standard rate for your license, and bring the gap to the rate conversation. Our guide to negotiating insurance contract rates includes a sample letter for that request.

The contracted rate is only half of the picture. Fuse tracks what Anthem and your other payers actually pay on your claims, so you can see which payers pay what they agreed and which do not.

Disclaimer: This article uses rate information from the Machine Readable Files that Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield publishes under the federal Transparency in Coverage rule. These files are posted to satisfy the regulation, not to be read. The data behind this analysis unpacks to 67 gigabytes of raw pricing, millions of negotiated rates that no spreadsheet can open. Fuse built software that reads it in full and verifies the figures above. This analysis focuses on a single payer and will not reflect rates from all available insurance options in Wisconsin. Fuse makes every effort to provide accurate and current information, but healthcare pricing can change frequently, and individual circumstances may affect actual costs. This information does not guarantee specific pricing. Practices should verify current rates directly with Anthem before relying on them for billing or negotiation decisions.

Sample Fuse revenue report: $5,720 denied or billed to patients for reasons an insurance check catches up frontSample Fuse coverage prediction: coverage answerable instantly for 62% of visits

See the full sample report, or get this run on your own claims.

Illustration comparing allowed amounts to paid amounts per payer, with an underpayment flagged and a recovered claim checked off
Fuse Revenue Analytics
Put your claims data to work

Fuse builds a model of payer behavior from your claims: underpayments flagged, lapsed plans caught, coverage predicted for scheduled patients.

Get Your Free Revenue Analysis

FAQs

What does Anthem pay for a 60-minute therapy session in Wisconsin?

Most Wisconsin therapists are listed at $131.96 for CPT 90837 in Anthem's November 2026 files. Counselors, clinical social workers and marriage and family therapists share that rate in every network, and 80 percent of them have it. Across every clinician and rate, the median was $150.43 and the mean $252.70, because separate contracts list some clinicians at far higher amounts.

Does Wisconsin require Anthem to pay the same rate for telehealth therapy?

No. Wisconsin has no law requiring commercial insurers to cover telehealth or to pay it at the in-person rate. A telehealth parity mandate has been proposed in three consecutive state budgets and removed each time. What Anthem pays for a virtual 90837 in Wisconsin is set by the contract. Wisconsin Medicaid is the opposite. State law requires ForwardHealth to reimburse telehealth, and its policy pays distant-site providers the same rate as face-to-face care, including audio-only visits for functionally equivalent services.

Who is Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield in Wisconsin?

It is a trade name shared by Elevance Health companies. Anthem's 2024 Wisconsin provider disclosure names three. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Wisconsin underwrites PPO and indemnity plans, Compcare Health Services Insurance Corporation underwrites HMO and POS plans, and Wisconsin Collaborative Insurance Company underwrites Well Priority HMO and POS plans. Compcare is the Anthem company that sells individual marketplace plans.

What does Anthem reimburse for a psychiatric diagnostic evaluation in Wisconsin?

Most Wisconsin therapists are listed at $135.03 for CPT 90791, the psychiatric diagnostic evaluation, and most psychologists at $156.00, in Anthem's November 2026 files. Across every clinician and rate, the median was $156.00 and the mean $272.08. What a specific visit allows depends on the member's plan and the clinician's contract.

How does Wisconsin Medicaid pay for therapy compared with Anthem?

Wisconsin Medicaid pays from a fixed fee schedule with two tiers. Psychiatrists, prescribing psychiatric nurses and doctoral-level psychologists get the higher rate, and master's-level clinicians get the lower one. The rates rose 15 percent in January 2022 and have not risen since. BadgerCare Plus HMOs set their own rates, which can differ. Unlike an Anthem contract, none of it is negotiated clinician by clinician.