Resources>Reimbursement Rates

UnitedHealthcare Behavioral Health Reimbursement Rates in New York (2026)

FUSE TEAM
October 30, 20269 min read

UnitedHealthcare’s Optum network lists most New York therapists with their own contract at $121.33 for a 90837 session downstate and $110.30 upstate. Both are about 11 percent below what Medicare pays the same therapists in the same area.

Optum, UnitedHealthcare’s sister company, runs its behavioral health network for UnitedHealthcare and Oxford and publishes one national rate file for it. We read the October 2026 copy and kept clinicians whose practice address in the federal NPI registry is in New York. Nearly half of New York therapists in the file are listed under a contract with Headway or Alma. Of the 11 states in our UnitedHealthcare 90837 rates by state, only Colorado comes close. So this page separates those rates from therapists’ own contracts.

Which UnitedHealthcare and Oxford Plans Use These Rates?

Probably most of them, because Optum signs up behavioral health clinicians for UnitedHealthcare. UnitedHealthcare’s provider site says Optum “handles credentialing and contracting on behalf of UnitedHealthcare,” so a therapist who joins UnitedHealthcare or Oxford gets an Optum rate.

UnitedHealthcare’s public disclosures are less clear. Federal rules require it to publish, for each plan, which rate files apply. In New York it names Optum’s file for only a small share of plans.

  • Oxford Health Insurance. Optum’s file is named for 6,127 of the 51,822 plans it lists, about 12 percent.
  • UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company of New York. Named for 95 of 939 plans, about 10 percent.

Another 15 UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company of New York plans name a second, much larger behavioral health file instead. The rest name only medical, dental, vision and other files. We did not read UnitedHealthcare’s New York medical files. In Illinois, its three largest medical files each listed only about 410 to 460 behavioral health clinicians, mostly hospital systems and community health centers. So the low share most likely means the disclosures are incomplete, not that most plans use a different network. Ask which network a patient’s plan uses when you verify benefits.

Three more limits apply. These counts are plans, not people covered. Medicare Advantage and Medicaid plans are not part of these disclosures. A listed rate does not mean the clinician takes new UnitedHealthcare patients.

What Does Optum Pay New York Clinicians for 90837, 90791 and 96130?

The table pools every New York license type and contract, including Headway and Alma. We used only the dollar rates Optum lists for clinicians’ own services, not facility rates. Each clinician’s rate counts once, even when it appears under several contracts.

CPT Code Description Mean Negotiated Rate Median Negotiated Rate Min Max Unique NPI Count
90791 Psychiatric Diagnostic Evaluation $157.48 $144.40 $74.75 $639.25 13,430
90837 Psychotherapy, 60 minutes $136.76 $137.78 $74.50 $739.94 13,427
96130 Psychological Testing Evaluation, 1st hour $122.84 $120.30 $78.54 $699.53 6,542

Rates extracted from the Optum behavioral health file in UnitedHealthcare’s October 2026 machine readable files.

The 90837 median of $137.78 is Headway’s rate, not a typical own-contract rate. It lands there because so many New York therapists are listed under Headway and psychologists’ rates sit higher. The sections below break the rates apart by region, license and contract.

Does Optum Pay Downstate Therapists More Than Upstate?

Yes, about 10 percent more. Among therapists with their own Optum contract, not a platform’s, the most common 90837 rate is $121.33 downstate and $110.30 upstate.

Region Own-contract therapists Most common 90837 rate
New York City 1,593 $121.33 for 80%
Long Island 1,128 $121.33 for 93%
Hudson Valley and Capital Region 1,274 Split: $110.30 for 37%, $121.33 for 31%, $115.82 for 25%
Rest of upstate 929 $110.30 for 84%

Therapists means counselors, social workers and marriage and family therapists. We grouped them by the ZIP code on their NPI registry practice address. New York City is ZIP codes starting 100 to 104, 110 to 114 and 116, and Long Island 115 and 117 to 119. Hudson Valley and Capital Region is 105 to 109 and 120 to 129, and the rest of upstate 130 to 149.

The Hudson Valley and Capital Region mix all three rates, so a therapist there should check which one their contract uses. The same downstate and upstate split runs through every license. Psychologists’ most common rate is $161.78 downstate and $147.07 upstate, and psychiatric nurse practitioners’ is $137.51 and $125.01.

How Do Optum’s New York Rates Compare With Medicare?

They run about 11 percent below Medicare for every license, in both regions. Medicare pays counselors, social workers and marriage and family therapists 75 percent of its full rate and nurse practitioners 85 percent. Optum’s rates follow the same steps.

License Optum downstate Medicare downstate Optum upstate Medicare upstate
Therapists $121.33 $136.48 to $137.42 $110.30 $123.60
Psychiatric NPs $137.51 $154.67 to $155.75 $125.01 $140.08
Psychologists $161.78 $181.97 to $183.23 $147.07 $164.80

Optum figures are the most common 90837 rate for each license. Medicare figures are 2026 office rates for 90837 in Manhattan, Queens and the New York City suburbs and Long Island (downstate), and the rest of New York (upstate), at the share Medicare pays each license.

So a downstate therapist on the $121.33 rate is listed at $15 to $16 less per session than Medicare pays. Medicare is a useful number to bring to a rate request, because Optum’s rates follow the same license steps.

Do Headway and Alma Have Higher Rates in New York?

Yes. Of the 9,149 New York therapists with an Optum rate for 90837, 46 percent are listed under a Headway or Alma contract, and 59 percent in New York City. Colorado is the same, 46 percent. In Texas it is 30 percent and in Illinois 6 percent. Anthem’s New York files list 52 percent of therapists under Headway or Alma, and our New York therapy rates by payer page compares the two payers for the same therapists.

  • Headway. 2,764 therapists, about 30 percent, at $137.78. That is 14 percent above the downstate rate and 25 percent above the upstate rate.
  • Alma. 1,693 therapists, about 19 percent, at $144.40, which is 19 percent above the downstate rate.
  • SonderMind. Only 15 New York therapists, at $127.32.

Headway’s $137.78 is close to what Medicare pays downstate therapists. These are the rates listed under each platform’s contract with Optum, not what the clinician takes home, which depends on each platform’s terms. Our UnitedHealthcare Texas rates cover how these platform contracts work, and our state comparison shows that each platform has the same rate in every state.

What Does Optum Pay New York Psychologists for Testing?

It depends on the therapy rate. Each psychologist’s 90837 rate comes with a matching 96130 testing rate.

  • $161.78 for therapy. 1,047 psychologists, all with $132.33 for the first testing hour.
  • $147.07 for therapy. 328 psychologists, all with $120.30 for testing.

Both testing rates are below the matching therapy rate. The downstate one, $132.33, is also below Medicare’s downstate 96130 rate of $136.89 to $138.66. Testing evaluations also bill added hours and test administration codes, so price the whole evaluation when you compare.

Does New York Law Change What UnitedHealthcare Must Pay?

Not for private practice rates. Two New York rules come up often, and neither sets a rate for a therapist’s own practice.

  • The Medicaid rate floor. Since 2025, New York requires insurers to pay at least the Medicaid rate for outpatient care at certain licensed clinics. These are clinics licensed by the Office of Mental Health or the Office of Addiction Services and Supports. The state’s FAQ lists the clinic types it covers. It applies only to fully insured plans, and private practices are not on the list.
  • Telehealth pay. Insurance Law 3217-h requires insurers to pay for covered telehealth services at the same rate as in person. The 2026 state budget extended it until April 1, 2028. It covers fully insured plans, not self-funded employer plans.

So for a private practice, the rate is whatever your Optum contract says, and video sessions for fully insured patients should pay the same.

What This Means for Your Practice

Optum’s New York rates follow a simple pattern, which makes your own rate easy to check. Three things to do now.

  • Find your rate in the tables. If your 90837 rate is below $121.33 downstate or $110.30 upstate for a therapist, or below the matching rate for your license, ask Optum why.
  • Use Medicare as your benchmark. Optum pays about 89 percent of Medicare across licenses, so a request to move closer to Medicare is easy to explain.
  • Weigh a platform against your own contract. Downstate, Headway and Alma list 14 to 19 percent more than the most common own-contract rate. Compare what you would take home under each, after the platform’s terms.

Our guide to negotiating insurance contract rates covers how to make the request. Optum’s Provider Services line is 877-614-0484.

Disclaimer: This article uses rate information from the Machine Readable Files that UnitedHealthcare publishes under the federal Transparency in Coverage rule. The Optum behavioral health file is about 80 megabytes unzipped and lists rates for more than 175,000 provider ID numbers nationwide with no names attached. Medicare figures are our calculation from the 2026 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule October release. Fuse built its own software to match these rates to clinicians and verify the figures above. This analysis covers a single payer and will not reflect rates from all available insurance options in New York. We name platforms only to identify their contracts in the file, not to describe what they pay their clinicians. Healthcare pricing changes frequently, and individual circumstances affect actual payment. Practices should verify current rates directly with UnitedHealthcare before relying on them for billing or negotiation decisions.

Sample Fuse revenue report: $5,720 denied or billed to patients for reasons an insurance check catches up frontSample Fuse coverage prediction: coverage answerable instantly for 62% of visits

See the full sample report, or get this run on your own claims.

Illustration comparing allowed amounts to paid amounts per payer, with an underpayment flagged and a recovered claim checked off
Fuse Revenue Analytics
Put your claims data to work

Fuse builds a model of payer behavior from your claims: underpayments flagged, lapsed plans caught, coverage predicted for scheduled patients.

Get Your Free Revenue Analysis

FAQs

Which UnitedHealthcare and Oxford plans use these Optum rates in New York?

Probably most of them. UnitedHealthcare says Optum handles credentialing and contracting for behavioral health clinicians on its behalf. But its October 2026 disclosures name the Optum file for only about 12 percent of Oxford Health Insurance plans and 10 percent of UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company of New York plans. Ask which network the member's plan uses for behavioral health when you verify benefits.

Does New York require UnitedHealthcare to pay private practices at least Medicaid rates?

No. New York's Medicaid-rate rule for commercial insurers covers outpatient care at clinics licensed by the Office of Mental Health or the Office of Addiction Services and Supports, and only for fully insured plans. A therapist or psychologist in private practice is not covered by it.

Does UnitedHealthcare pay the same rate for telehealth therapy in New York?

For fully insured plans, yes. New York Insurance Law 3217-h requires insurers to pay for covered telehealth services at the same rate as in person, and that rule runs until April 1, 2028. Self-funded employer plans are not bound by it.