Resources>Reimbursement Rates

Ohio Therapy Reimbursement Rates by Payer: Anthem vs UnitedHealthcare (2026)

FUSE TEAM
November 09, 202611 min read

In Ohio, UnitedHealthcare’s Optum network pays more than Anthem for most therapists, whether they hold their own contract or join through Headway or SonderMind. Optum’s standard Ohio rate for a 60-minute session is about 19 percent above Anthem’s, and Optum pays more for 86 percent of the therapists both payers list.

The Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield figures cover its nine main Ohio network files from November 2026, Pathway HMO, Pathway tiered and Blue Access. Anthem’s index names those files for nearly all of its Ohio plan listings, counted by plans, not members. The UnitedHealthcare figures come from the behavioral health network that Optum, UnitedHealthcare’s sister company, runs for UnitedHealthcare plans, from October 2026. Read them as Optum’s network rates, for reasons the next section explains.

How Did We Compare Ohio Payers’ Therapy Rates?

We read each payer’s own rate files and kept clinicians whose registered practice address is in Ohio.

  • Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield. Its nine main Ohio network files for November 2026, including the largest Blue Access file, which Anthem splits into 13 parts. Our Anthem behavioral health rates for Ohio page covers the same files.
  • UnitedHealthcare. Optum’s October 2026 behavioral health file. It covers Optum’s whole national network, so we kept only Ohio clinicians. UnitedHealthcare of Ohio’s own November disclosure lists 61 plans and names only medical and specialty network files for them, not this one. Ohio’s other UnitedHealthcare plans report under national or employer disclosures that are not split by state. UnitedHealthcare’s provider site says Optum handles behavioral health credentialing and contracting for UnitedHealthcare, so we treat this file as the rate list for its behavioral health network. We checked Optum’s November file too. Fewer than 1 percent of Ohio 90837 listings changed, and none of the common amounts moved.

We matched every provider ID number against the federal NPPES registry and kept individual behavioral health clinicians. We kept dollar rates and dropped percentage and placeholder rows. The table counts each distinct clinician and rate pair once.

Of the 9,875 Ohio clinicians Optum lists with a 90837 rate, 8,334 also have Anthem rates, about five in six. That let us compare what each payer pays the same person. Anthem lists 35 percent of its clinicians at more than one 90837 rate, against 5 percent at Optum. So for each clinician we took the middle of their Anthem amounts, half above it and half below, and compared that with their Optum rate.

We also sorted rates by who holds the contract. Both files list each rate under a tax ID or an organization’s NPI. A rate listed under one of Headway’s, SonderMind’s or Alma’s own legal entities counts as a platform rate. Everything else counts as the clinician’s own contract, including group practices. We split the state into five regions by practice ZIP code, with Cleveland and Akron in the Northeast, Columbus in Central Ohio and Cincinnati and Dayton in the Southwest.

Ohio Therapy Reimbursement Rates by Payer (2026 Table)

CPT Code Service Payer Median Rate Mean Rate Unique NPI Count Data Month
90837 Psychotherapy, 60 min Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield $109.08 $162.99 19,302 November 2026
90837 Psychotherapy, 60 min UnitedHealthcare $110.30 $134.56 9,997 October 2026
90791 Psychiatric Diagnostic Evaluation Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield $113.10 $175.70 19,356 November 2026
90791 Psychiatric Diagnostic Evaluation UnitedHealthcare $131.15 $156.22 9,962 October 2026
96130 Psych. Testing Evaluation (1st hr) Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield $84.55 $136.48 18,598 November 2026
96130 Psych. Testing Evaluation (1st hr) UnitedHealthcare $120.30 $171.39 2,131 October 2026

Each row comes from that payer’s machine readable files for the month shown, filtered to individual behavioral health clinicians with an Ohio practice address.

The two 90837 medians look nearly tied, $109.08 at Anthem and $110.30 at Optum. The tie hides the gap. Anthem’s median counts every rate a clinician holds, and a third of its clinicians hold more than one, including platform and large group amounts well above its standard rate. For one therapist with one contract at each payer, Optum usually pays more. The next sections compare the same people. Optum also leads on 90791 and on testing, where its median is more than 40 percent above Anthem’s.

Which Payer Pays Ohio Therapists More on Their Own Contract?

Optum does, for 87 percent of the 4,678 therapists with their own contract at both payers. For 85 percent, Optum’s lowest rate beats Anthem’s highest.

Both payers set one standard therapist rate for the whole state. Optum lists 84 percent of its Ohio therapists at $110.30 for 90837. Anthem lists 83 percent of its therapists at $92.74, so Optum’s standard is about 19 percent higher. Anthem’s amount rarely changes by network. Of the therapists it lists, 71 percent have the same 90837 amount in every Anthem file they appear in. Counselors, clinical social workers and marriage and family therapists all sit at the same standard amounts.

Optum’s lead holds in every region but is smaller in Columbus and Cincinnati.

  • Northeast, Northwest and Southeast. Optum pays more for 91 to 95 percent of therapists on their own contract at both payers.
  • Central Ohio. Optum pays more for 81 percent. About 19 percent of Anthem’s Central Ohio therapists are also listed under a group contract at $200 or more for 90837, against about 6 percent in the Northeast.
  • Southwest. Optum pays more for 78 percent. About 9 percent of Anthem’s Southwest therapists are listed under a group contract at $200 or more.

The diagnostic evaluation shows a wider gap. Optum’s standard 90791 rate of $131.15 is about 36 percent above Anthem’s $96.16, and Optum pays more for 90 percent of the therapists both list.

Does Anthem or Optum Pay More to Ohio Therapists on Headway or SonderMind?

Optum does. It pays more for every one of the 165 Headway therapists and 259 SonderMind therapists listed under that platform at both payers.

Platforms hold a much bigger share of Anthem’s Ohio therapists than of Optum’s. Anthem lists 16 percent of its therapists under Headway and 9 percent under SonderMind. Optum lists about 6 percent under any platform. Alma has no Anthem listings in Ohio.

  • Headway. Anthem pays Headway therapists $122.06, about 32 percent above its standard rate. Optum pays them $137.78, about 25 percent above its own standard.
  • SonderMind. Anthem pays SonderMind therapists $106.66, and Optum pays $127.32. Each payer’s SonderMind rate is about 15 percent above its standard.

There is one case where Anthem comes out ahead. Anthem’s Headway rate of $122.06 beats Optum’s own-contract $110.30 by about 11 percent. That matters if you would join Anthem through Headway but hold your own Optum contract, as 64 therapists in both files do. Two in three Anthem Headway therapists are also listed under their own Anthem contract at the standard rate. The files list both, and which one pays depends on whose tax ID is on the claim. What you take home through a platform depends on your agreement with it.

Which Payer Pays Ohio Psychologists and Psychiatric NPs More for Therapy?

Optum pays more for about two in three. Its 90837 rate beats Anthem’s middle rate for 63 percent of psychologists and 66 percent of psychiatric nurse practitioners both payers list.

  • Psychologists. Optum’s most common rate is $147.07, about 35 percent above Anthem’s most common $109.11. In the Southwest, Anthem’s group contracts pay many psychologists more, and the two payers split about evenly there.
  • Psychiatric nurse practitioners. Optum’s most common rate is $125.01, about 15 percent above Anthem’s $109.08. Anthem lists about one in seven psychiatric NPs under Headway at $144.67.
  • Psychiatrists. The two payers split about evenly. Anthem’s middle rate is higher for 52 percent of the 721 on both lists. Most psychiatrists bill medication visits with other codes, so treat this as a secondary comparison.

Which Payer Pays More for Psychological Testing (96130) in Ohio?

Optum pays psychologists more for the first testing hour. Its rate beats Anthem’s middle rate for 76 percent of the 1,034 psychologists both payers list.

Optum lists most of those psychologists at $120.30. Anthem lists most of them at two amounts, $99.48 and $93.86, so Optum pays about 21 percent more than Anthem’s higher one. For a psychologist, Optum’s testing rate tracks its therapy rate. Psychologists at $147.07 for 90837 get $120.30 for 96130.

Anthem attaches a 96130 rate to far more clinicians, including about 13,000 therapists through group contracts, mostly at $79.78 or $84.55. Optum lists 198 therapists with one. Those listings matter only where your license lets you bill testing.

How Long Can an Ohio Payer Take to Credential You?

Ninety days from when it receives your application. After that, the payer owes you $500 a day or back pay, but only if Ohio’s law names your license.

Revised Code section 3963.06 sets the clock. The Ohio Department of Insurance’s guidance says it applies to provider networks as well as insurers, and to any company that credentials on a payer’s behalf. The payer that hands the work off stays responsible.

  • When the clock starts. It starts on the day the payer receives your application, sent after the payer asks for it. Send it by email, fax or certified mail so you can show the date. You may apply before your start date.
  • Incomplete applications. The payer must tell you what is missing within 21 days.
  • After day 90. The payer must pay either $500 a day, weekends included, or pay your claims at contract rates back to day 90 until it decides. The payer picks which one and must tell you.
  • What it covers. First-time credentialing only, not recredentialing. Medicaid managed care plans count, but direct contracts with Ohio Medicaid or Medicare do not.

The law’s list of providers names licensed professional counselors and clinical counselors, psychologists, advanced practice registered nurses and physicians. It does not name social workers or marriage and family therapists. If that is your license, apply early and follow up in writing, because the 90-day remedy may not reach you.

The same chapter covers fee schedules. For the licenses the law names, a contract must include the fee schedule for the codes your specialty is expected to bill, or the method behind it. You can ask for a written copy up to twice a year. Ask for it before you sign, since Anthem lists a third of Ohio clinicians at more than one 90837 rate.

Which Payer Should an Ohio Clinician Credential With First?

For most licenses, Optum. Its standard rates beat Anthem’s for therapists, psychologists and psychiatric NPs, so an Optum application usually adds more per session.

  • Therapists on their own contract. Apply to Optum first. It pays $110.30 for 90837, about 19 percent above Anthem’s $92.74, and its 90791 rate is about 36 percent higher.
  • Therapists joining through Headway or SonderMind. Optum pays more through either platform. If you would join Anthem only through Headway, its $122.06 still beats Optum’s own-contract rate.
  • Psychologists. Apply to Optum first. It pays $147.07 for 90837 to most psychologists, against Anthem’s $109.11, and about 21 percent more for testing. In the Southwest, ask Anthem what group rate you would get.
  • Psychiatric nurse practitioners. Apply to Optum first, at $125.01 against Anthem’s $109.08 on your own contract. Through Headway, Anthem’s $144.67 beats Optum’s own-contract rate, but Optum’s Headway rate of $156.16 is higher still.
  • Social workers and marriage and family therapists. The same rate order applies, but Ohio’s 90-day credentialing remedy does not name your license, so send both applications early.

Anthem lists about twice as many Ohio clinicians as Optum, so both contracts are worth holding. The order decides which patients a new clinician can see first and at what rate. If an offer sits well below these figures, our guide to negotiating insurance contract rates covers how to ask for more. For other states, see our New York therapy rates by payer and UnitedHealthcare 90837 rates by state.

The contracted rate is only half of the picture. Fuse tracks what every payer actually pays on your claims, so you can see which payers pay what they agreed and which do not.

Disclaimer: This article uses rate information from the Machine Readable Files that Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield and UnitedHealthcare publish under the federal Transparency in Coverage rule. These files are posted to satisfy the regulation, not to be read, and Fuse built its own software to extract and verify the figures above. This analysis covers two payers and will not reflect rates from every insurer in Ohio. Healthcare pricing changes frequently, and individual contracts and circumstances affect actual payment. This information does not guarantee specific pricing. Practices should verify current rates directly with each payer before relying on them for billing or negotiation decisions.

Sample Fuse revenue report: $5,720 denied or billed to patients for reasons an insurance check catches up frontSample Fuse coverage prediction: coverage answerable instantly for 62% of visits

See the full sample report, or get this run on your own claims.

Illustration comparing allowed amounts to paid amounts per payer, with an underpayment flagged and a recovered claim checked off
Fuse Revenue Analytics
Which of your Ohio payers pays you the most?

Fuse compares what Anthem, UnitedHealthcare and your other payers actually paid on your claims with your contracted rates and the Ohio medians.

Get Your Free Analysis

FAQs

Does UnitedHealthcare pay Ohio therapists less than other states?

Yes, it pays them less than most. Optum's behavioral health network, which serves UnitedHealthcare plans, has an Ohio 90837 median of $110.30, tied with Texas, Michigan and Virginia for the lowest of the 12 states we compared. New York's median is $137.78. Optum still pays Ohio therapists more than Anthem does for most clinicians both payers list.

Do these Anthem rates include Ohio marketplace plans?

Yes. Two of the nine Anthem files list its Ohio marketplace networks by name next to its Pathway networks, and four Blue Access files cover its employer plans. Medicaid managed care plans do not publish these rate files, so Anthem's Ohio Medicaid rates are not included.

Why are Aetna, CareSource, Cigna and Medical Mutual not in this Ohio comparison?

We have not read their Ohio rate files yet. A fair comparison needs each payer's full Ohio network, and we add payers to this page as we read them.