Resources>Reimbursement Rates

New York Therapy Reimbursement Rates by Payer: Anthem vs UnitedHealthcare (2026)

FUSE TEAM
November 05, 202612 min read

In New York, which payer pays a therapist more depends on how the therapist contracts. UnitedHealthcare’s Optum network pays more than Anthem for a 60-minute session to 96 percent of therapists who hold their own contract with both. For therapists who contract through Headway, Anthem pays more than Optum for nearly every one both payers list.

The Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield figures cover its four New York employer group networks, from November 2026. Anthem’s index names those files for about 99 percent of the group plans it lists, counted by plans, not members, and they leave out its individual plans. The UnitedHealthcare figures come from the behavioral health network that Optum, UnitedHealthcare’s sister company, runs for UnitedHealthcare and Oxford plans, from October 2026.

How Did We Compare New York Payers’ Therapy Rates?

We read each payer’s own rate files and kept clinicians whose registered practice address is in New York.

  • Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield. Its BlueAccess large group, EPO, small group EPO and Connection small group files for November 2026. Our Anthem behavioral health rates for New York page covers the same files.
  • UnitedHealthcare. Optum’s October 2026 behavioral health file. It covers Optum’s whole national network, so we kept only New York clinicians. UnitedHealthcare’s disclosures name this file for about 12 percent of Oxford plans and 10 percent of UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company of New York plans, but its provider site says Optum handles behavioral health contracting for UnitedHealthcare. Our UnitedHealthcare behavioral health rates for New York page covers that gap. We checked Optum’s November file too. Fewer than 1 percent of New York 90837 listings changed, and none of the common amounts moved.

We matched every provider ID number against the federal NPPES registry and kept individual behavioral health clinicians. We kept dollar rates and dropped percentage and placeholder rows. The table counts each distinct clinician and rate pair once.

Of the 13,312 New York clinicians Optum lists with a 90837 rate, 10,175 also have Anthem rates, about three in four. That let us compare what each payer pays the same person. Anthem lists 88 percent of its clinicians at more than one 90837 rate, usually a different amount in each network. Optum lists 12 percent at more than one. So for each clinician we took the middle of their Anthem amounts, half above it and half below, and compared that with their Optum rate.

We also sorted rates by who holds the contract. Both files list each rate under a tax ID or an organization’s NPI. A rate listed under Headway’s or Alma’s own legal entities counts as a platform rate. Everything else counts as the clinician’s own contract, including group practices. We split the state into New York City, Long Island, the Hudson Valley and Capital Region, and upstate by practice ZIP code.

New York Therapy Reimbursement Rates by Payer (2026 Table)

CPT Code Service Payer Median Rate Mean Rate Unique NPI Count Data Month
90837 Psychotherapy, 60 min Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield $106.33 $132.73 31,296 November 2026
90837 Psychotherapy, 60 min UnitedHealthcare $137.78 $136.76 13,427 October 2026
90791 Psychiatric Diagnostic Evaluation Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield $118.45 $149.58 31,296 November 2026
90791 Psychiatric Diagnostic Evaluation UnitedHealthcare $144.40 $157.48 13,430 October 2026
96130 Psych. Testing Evaluation (1st hr) Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield $115.66 $132.46 31,296 November 2026
96130 Psych. Testing Evaluation (1st hr) UnitedHealthcare $120.30 $122.84 6,542 October 2026

Each row comes from that payer’s machine readable files for the month shown, filtered to individual behavioral health clinicians with a New York practice address.

Optum leads on 90837 and 90791. Its 90837 median of $137.78 is about 30 percent above Anthem’s $106.33. Anthem lists more than twice as many clinicians, and about half of its therapists are listed under Headway or Alma, so the medians mix two very different kinds of contract. The next two sections separate them. On testing, the two payers sit within about 4 percent of each other.

Which Payer Pays New York Therapists More on Their Own Contract?

Optum does, for 96 percent of the 4,018 therapists with their own contract at both payers. The gap is about 25 percent downstate and 14 percent upstate.

Anthem’s middle own-contract rate for these therapists is $97.44 in every region except the Hudson Valley and Capital Region, where it is $97.64. Optum’s rate steps down from the city.

  • New York City and Long Island. Optum pays $121.33, about 25 percent above the Anthem middle.
  • Hudson Valley and Capital Region. Optum pays $115.82, about 19 percent above.
  • Upstate. Optum pays $110.30, about 14 percent above.

Anthem’s own-contract amounts change by network more than by region. The most common ones run from $85.26 to $109.62, and the same therapist often has a different amount in each network. Counselors, clinical social workers and marriage and family therapists all show the same pattern.

Does Anthem or Optum Pay More to New York Therapists on Headway or Alma?

Anthem does for Headway therapists and Alma social workers. Optum does for most Alma counselors and marriage and family therapists.

Headway and Alma hold a bigger share of Anthem’s New York therapists than of Optum’s. Anthem lists 52 percent of its New York therapists under a Headway or Alma contract, against 46 percent in Optum’s file.

  • Headway. Anthem pays Headway social workers $167.83 in BlueAccess large group, the EPO and the small group EPO. About half of Headway counselors and marriage and family therapists get $184.61, 10 percent more. Headway’s Anthem contract barely reaches the Connection small group network, which lists 26 Headway therapists. Optum pays Headway therapists $137.78. Anthem pays more for 2,236 of the 2,241 therapists listed under Headway at both payers, typically about 22 percent more.
  • Alma. Anthem pays Alma social workers $181.51 in the EPO and small group EPO, $163.36 in BlueAccess large group and $145.21 in Connection small group. Optum pays Alma therapists $144.40. Anthem pays more for 679 of the 682 Alma social workers on both lists. More than 40 percent of Alma counselors and marriage and family therapists sit on a lower Anthem tier, $111.01 to $138.77, so Optum pays more for 78 percent of the 491 on both lists.

The two payers price platforms very differently. Optum pays Headway and Alma 14 to 19 percent more than its downstate own-contract rate. Anthem’s Headway rate of $167.83 is about 72 percent above its middle own-contract rate. The files show what the payer pays on a claim billed under the platform’s tax ID. What you take home depends on your agreement with the platform.

Which Payer Pays New York Psychologists and Psychiatric NPs More for Therapy?

Optum, for most of them. Its 90837 rate beats Anthem’s middle rate for 85 percent of psychologists and 70 percent of psychiatric nurse practitioners both payers list.

  • Psychologists. Optum lists 44 percent of New York psychologists at $161.78, and about two in three upstate psychologists at $147.07. On their own contract, Anthem pays psychologists about what it pays therapists, a median of $101.09. About a quarter of Anthem’s psychologists are listed under Headway at $167.83 or $184.61. For the 1,574 psychologists on both lists, Optum pays about $56 more than the Anthem middle.
  • Psychiatric nurse practitioners. Optum’s most common rate is $137.51. Anthem’s own-contract median is $106.33, but it lists 45 percent of psychiatric NPs under Headway at $167.83. For the 575 on both lists, Optum pays about $20 more than the Anthem middle.
  • Psychiatrists. Optum pays more for 69 percent of the 948 on both lists, by about $40. Most psychiatrists bill medication visits with other codes, so treat this as a secondary comparison.

The diagnostic evaluation follows the same pattern. Optum’s 90791 rate beats the Anthem middle for 63 percent of therapists and 81 percent of psychologists listed by both.

Which Payer Pays More for Psychological Testing (96130) in New York?

Anthem pays therapists more, and the two payers are close for psychologists. Anthem lists $128.52 for the first testing hour for 80 percent of psychologists and 85 percent of therapists, often alongside lower amounts under other contracts. For most clinicians both payers list, $128.52 is also the middle of their Anthem amounts.

  • Psychologists. Optum pays $132.33 in New York City and on Long Island, about 3 percent above Anthem. It pays $126.32 in the Hudson Valley and Capital Region and $120.30 upstate, below Anthem.
  • Counselors and social workers. Optum lists them at $110.93, and Anthem’s $128.52 is higher for 84 percent of the 2,444 on both lists. These listings come with group contracts that price every code for everyone in the group, so they matter only where your license lets you bill testing.

For a psychologist, Optum’s testing rate tracks its therapy rate. Psychologists at $161.78 for 90837 get $132.33 for 96130, and those at $147.07 get $120.30.

Must New York Plans Pay Telehealth Therapy at the In-Person Rate?

Yes, for plans New York regulates, until April 1, 2028. State law requires the same rate as an in-person visit, and state rules count phone-only sessions as telehealth.

Insurance Law section 3217-h sets the rule for insurers, and section 4306-g repeats it for nonprofit plans. Plans with comprehensive coverage must pay telehealth “on the same basis, at the same rate, and to the same extent” as the same service in person. A state insurance regulation (11 NYCRR 52.16) counts the telephone as telehealth, so audio-only sessions are included.

  • The end date. The rate rule is written to expire on April 1, 2028. After that date, plans must still cover telehealth, but the law no longer sets the rate. New York added the rate rule in 2022 and has extended it twice, most recently in a law signed May 28, 2026. We read the current statute text on November 5, 2026.
  • Self-funded employer plans. Federal law governs them, so New York’s rule does not reach them. Their telehealth rate follows your contract and the plan’s own policy.
  • Anthem’s policy. Anthem’s New York virtual visits policy (approved June 28, 2023) pays professional telehealth claims at its “non-office” rate. It also says state mandates can override its policies. An April 1, 2024 Anthem provider notice said virtual visits are “reimbursed at the non-office rate” from July 1, 2024.
  • Optum’s policy. Optum’s commercial telemental health policy, updated October 2026, sets billing rules, place of service 02 or 10 and modifier 93 for audio-only, but names no separate telehealth rate.

Anthem’s files cannot tell you what a video session pays. They list an office amount for every clinician and a separate non-office amount, usually 12.5 percent lower, for fewer than 1 percent of them. Neither covers telehealth places of service. So check your remittances. On a plan New York regulates, a telehealth 90837 should pay what the same session pays in your office. If Anthem pays less, cite section 3217-h or 4306-g when you appeal.

Which Payer Should a New York Clinician Credential With First?

It depends on license and on whether you contract on your own or through a platform. Each payer credentials clinicians separately, so the order decides which patients a new hire can see first and at what rate.

  • Therapists on their own contract. Apply to Optum first. It pays $121.33 for 90837 downstate, about 25 percent above Anthem’s typical own-contract rate, and $110.30 upstate, about 14 percent above.
  • Therapists joining through Headway. Anthem’s Headway rate beats Optum’s by about 22 percent. Ask which Anthem networks you join, since Headway’s contract barely covers Connection small group.
  • Therapists joining through Alma. For social workers, Anthem pays more in every network. For counselors and marriage and family therapists, ask which Anthem tier you would get. On the lower tier, Optum’s $144.40 is higher.
  • Psychologists. On your own contract, apply to Optum first. It pays $161.78 for 90837 to the largest group of psychologists, against Anthem’s own-contract median of $101.09. Its testing rate is within about $4 of Anthem’s for most psychologists.
  • Psychiatric nurse practitioners. On your own contract, apply to Optum first, at $137.51 against Anthem’s $106.33. Through Headway, Anthem’s $167.83 is higher.

Before you sign with Anthem, ask which networks the contract covers and what it pays in each, because the same clinician’s amount often differs by network. If an offer sits well below these figures, our guide to negotiating insurance contract rates covers how to ask for more. For other states, see our Illinois therapy rates by payer and UnitedHealthcare 90837 rates by state.

The contracted rate is only half of the picture. Fuse tracks what every payer actually pays on your claims, so you can see which payers pay what they agreed and which do not.

Disclaimer: This article uses rate information from the Machine Readable Files that Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield and UnitedHealthcare publish under the federal Transparency in Coverage rule. These files are posted to satisfy the regulation, not to be read, and Fuse built its own software to extract and verify the figures above. This analysis covers two payers and will not reflect rates from every insurer in New York. Healthcare pricing changes frequently, and individual contracts and circumstances affect actual payment. This information does not guarantee specific pricing. Practices should verify current rates directly with each payer before relying on them for billing or negotiation decisions.

Sample Fuse revenue report: $5,720 denied or billed to patients for reasons an insurance check catches up frontSample Fuse coverage prediction: coverage answerable instantly for 62% of visits

See the full sample report, or get this run on your own claims.

Illustration comparing allowed amounts to paid amounts per payer, with an underpayment flagged and a recovered claim checked off
Fuse Revenue Analytics
Which of your New York payers pays you the most?

Fuse compares what Anthem, UnitedHealthcare and your other payers actually paid on your claims with your contracted rates and the New York medians.

Get Your Free Analysis

FAQs

Does UnitedHealthcare pay New York therapists more than other states?

Yes, more than most. Optum's behavioral health network, which serves UnitedHealthcare and Oxford plans, has a New York 90837 median of $137.78, against $121.33 in California and $110.30 in Texas. Part of New York's lead comes from Headway and Alma, which carry nearly half of the state's therapists in the Optum file at higher rates.

Do these Anthem rates include New York individual plans?

No. The Anthem figures come from its four employer group network files. Anthem's New York individual-market file mostly lists other states' plans, so we left it out. Medicaid managed care plans do not publish these rate files.

Why are Aetna, Cigna, Fidelis and Healthfirst not in this New York comparison?

We have not read their New York rate files yet. A fair comparison needs each payer's full New York network, and we add payers to this page as we read them.